meta-analysis of 36 studies found higher cure rates with terbinafine (76%) than for pulsed itraconazole (63%), continuous itraconazole (59%), griseofulvin (60%) or fluconazole (48%) - ref: Br J Dermatol 2004; 150:537-44;
listed on PBS as authority item for proximal or extensive onychomycosis (>80% of nail), caused by dermatophyte proven by microscopy or culture when topical Rx has failed.
NB. topical antifungals have a very limited role here as only suitable for mild superficial, early infection of the distal part of the nail, and even then have a low cure rate and may require 12 months Rx or longer.
for onychomycosis, consider pulsed itraconazole (2-3 courses) if unable to tolerate terbinafine or if cause is candida